Comparing the Top 5 Litter Trays for Cats: Pros and Cons

Comparing the Top 5 Litter Trays for Cats: Pros and Cons

Why Choosing the Right Tray Matters

Cat litter trays are essential for providing a clean and comfortable environment for our kitty's butts.

However, given the various options available in the market, choosing the right type of litter tray can be a daunting task.

Cats are individual creatures with their own likes and dislikes.

Some are picky about litter type, while others may have strong preferences for a certain kind of box or a specific location.

In this article, we will examine five different types of cat litter trays and delve into their respective pros and cons, helping you make an informed decision that suits both your cat's needs and your lifestyle.

Although, let's first consider the basics.

 

 

Why a Cat Might Avoid Their Litter Tray

Why cats might avoid their litter tray
  • Perceived Threat from Outside:

Cats are more vigilant in environments where they perceive potential threats from other animals or predators.

This level of discomfort and stress can extend to their toilet behaviors. If a cat feels threatened or unsafe, it might avoid using an open litter tray situated in an area where it feels exposed.

  • Painful Urination or Elimination-Related Ailments:

Medical issues like urinary tract infections, kidney problems, or gastrointestinal issues can make using the litter box a painful experience.

Cats may associate this discomfort with the litter box itself, leading them to avoid it.

In such cases, immediate veterinary attention is essential to diagnose and treat the underlying condition.

  • Painful Paws:

Conditions like declawing, arthritis, or paw injuries can make stepping on litter painful for a cat.

In such cases, softer, finer-grained litters may be easier for the cat to tolerate. If your cat has painful paws, a vet visit is crucial to address the root of the issue.



Litter Box Size, Type, Location, or Number:

    • Size: Choose the right litter box for your cat's size. If the box is too small, large cats may find it cramped and uncomfortable.


While if it's too big, it can be hard to find a discreet and convenient location to set it up.

The ideal litter tray size for a cat is one and a half times the length of your cat from nose to the base of its tail.

This allows your cat to move around, dig and cover comfortably. You can measure your cat and find a suitable tray for them.

    • Location: For all animals, toilet time is a time of vulnerability. A box located in a high-traffic or noisy area may be off-putting. Similarly, if the box is too far away, a particularly lazy cat may not make the effort to use it.

    • Cats prefer quiet and discreet areas where they won’t be disturbed or threatened.

    • They also like to have a clear view of their surroundings when they are toileting, so they can spot any danger.

    • Avoid dark or enclosed places, and room corners.

    • Cats need easy and constant access to their litter tray, so avoid places that are too high, too far, or blocked by doors or obstacles.

    • Finally, like most people, cats don’t like to toilet near where they eat or drink, so keep the litter tray away from their food and water bowls.

 

    • Number: In multi-cat households, the general recommendation is one box per cat plus one extra. This helps reduce competition and territorial issues.

 

Rule out medical issues:
Why your cat might be avoiding their litter tray

If your cat seems uncomfortable or is avoiding the litter box, a multi-faceted approach is usually best.

As with all behavioral challenges or changes, start by ruling out medical issues with a vet visit.

Cat's are infamously good at hiding their pain and discomfort, and instead letting it manifest in destructive or unsociable behaviors'.

After medical causes have been ruled out, then you can start making adjustments to your kitty's litter box setup by taking into account the factors listed above.


1. Open Litter Trays:



Open litter trays are the most basic and traditional type of litter boxes, and they have both advantages and disadvantages. Here's a breakdown:

Pros


1. Easy to Clean: With no walls or roof, scooping and cleaning are straightforward tasks.

2. Affordable: Open trays are generally the most cost-effective option, making them accessible for all budgets.

3. Accessible: The lack of barriers makes it easy for cats of all sizes and mobility levels to use.

4. Visibility: It's easy to monitor the cleanliness of the box and to spot any potential health issues like bloody stools or changes in waste frequency.

5. Ventilation: The open design allows for better airflow, which can help minimize odors if the box is cleaned regularly.

6. Less Intimidating: For sensitive or skittish cats, the open design can be less frightening than enclosed or mechanical options.

7. Easy to Place: Without a need for electrical outlets or additional space for mechanical parts, these trays are simple to place anywhere.

Cons

1. Lack of Privacy: Some cats prefer a more private setting to do their business, which an open tray doesn’t offer.

2. Odor: Without a lid or purifying features, odors can spread more easily.

3. Mess: Active diggers can easily kick litter out of the box, creating more cleanup work.

4. Aesthetic: Open trays leave waste in plain sight, which some people may find unappealing.

5. No Additional Features: Unlike self-cleaning or self-purifying models, open trays don't offer any extra conveniences like waste removal or odor control.

6. Potential for Conflict: In multi-cat households, the lack of barriers can sometimes lead to territorial disputes.

7. Exposure: Open designs might be less hygienic as they expose the litter to the surrounding environment, increasing the risk of spreading germs or parasites.

In summary, open litter trays are an accessible, budget-friendly option that are easy to clean and monitor. However, they lack many of the features that can enhance privacy, odor control, and overall cleanliness. They may also not be the best choice for multi-cat households or for cats that prefer a more secluded environment.


 Although, litter scatter can be mitigated with the use of a litter mat!

Open litter trays are affordable and easy to clean, making them a practical choice for many cat owners.

Their accessibility accommodates cats of all sizes, and the open design aids in ventilation.

However, this openness can lead to more visible messes, less privacy for your cat, and increased odor.

In multi-cat homes, it may also result in territorial disputes. While open trays offer straightforward, low-cost convenience, they lack advanced features like odor control and automated waste removal found in more specialized models.

Overall, they're a basic yet functional option with some trade-offs.

You can explore our range of enclosed litter trays here!

2. Enclosed Trays:

enclosed cat litter tray

Enclosed litter trays are a popular choice among cat owners for their cleaner and tidier appearance.

The box's top cover conceals the litter from view, containing any potential mess or odor within the enclosure.

Furthermore, some cats prefer the privacy provided by an enclosed space, which can help them feel more secure and comfortable while using the litter box.



Pros

1. Reduced Litter Tracking: Litter mats catch stray particles as your cat leaves the litter box, preventing litter from being tracked around the house.

2. Easy Cleanup: Many litter mats are designed to be easy to clean. Some can be shaken out, vacuumed, or even rinsed off, making maintenance simple.

3. Aesthetically Pleasing: Litter mats come in various colors, shapes, and sizes, allowing you to choose one that fits well with your home decor.

4. Comfort for Pets: Some mats are made with soft materials that are gentle on your cat’s paws.

5. Additional Hygiene: By capturing stray litter, the mat can also help to contain potential germs or parasites that might otherwise be tracked onto floors.

6. Cost-Effective: Compared to other pet-care accessories like self-cleaning litter trays, litter mats are generally affordable.


Cons


1. Limited Effectiveness: While mats can reduce litter tracking, they can’t entirely eliminate it. Some stray litter is likely to escape, especially if your cat likes to dig or kick litter.

2. Regular Cleaning Required: Despite catching litter, the mats themselves need to be cleaned regularly to maintain their effectiveness and hygiene.

3. Occupies Space: Litter mats will take up extra floor space around the litter box, which might be a consideration in smaller living areas.

4. Chewing Hazard: Some cats might take an interest in chewing the mat, which could be harmful depending on the materials used.

5. Slipping: If not properly anchored, some litter mats may slip or slide around, especially on smooth flooring, which can be annoying or even hazardous.

6. Compatibility: Not all litter mats work well with all types of litter. For example, mats designed for larger particles might not be effective with finer litters.


In summary, litter mats offer a convenient and cost-effective solution for reducing litter tracking and enhancing cleanliness around the litter box.

They come in various styles to fit your decor and are generally easy to clean. However, they are not entirely foolproof, requiring regular maintenance, and may not be effective with all types of litter.

They also take up additional space and could present issues like slipping or chewing hazards.

3. Self-Cleaning Litter Trays:

Automated Self Cleaning Cat Litter tray

Pros:

 

  1. Convenience: One of the most significant benefits is the convenience factor. The tray automatically sifts and removes waste, reducing the frequency with which you need to clean it manually.
  2. Odor Control: Many self-cleaning trays are designed to minimize odors. This can make the living environment more pleasant for both you and your pet.
  3. Hygiene: Automated cleaning means that waste is removed quickly, generally resulting in a cleaner litter box, which is beneficial for your cat’s health.
  4. Time-Saving: A self-cleaning litter tray can save you a lot of time, especially if you have multiple cats or a hectic schedule.
  5. Data Monitoring: Some high-end models come with features like usage tracking, giving you insights into your cat’s health.
  6. Consistency: A self-cleaning tray ensures that the litter box remains consistently clean, which can be comforting to finicky felines.

Cons

  1. Cost: Self-cleaning litter trays are significantly more expensive upfront than traditional trays. The average cost for one of these high-tech pooper scoopers ranges from $600 to upwards of $1000.

  2. Maintenance: Despite being "self-cleaning," these units still require regular maintenance, such as refilling the litter, replacing waste receptacles, or cleaning out the mechanical components.

  3. Noise: The mechanical sifting action can be noisy, which might disturb you or your pet.

  4. Power Source: Most self-cleaning trays require an electrical outlet, which limits where you can place them. Battery-operated options may require frequent battery changes.

  5. Complexity: The more complex the unit, the more there is that can go wrong. Some cats may also find the mechanical action frightening or off-putting.

  6. Size and Weight: Self-cleaning trays are generally bulkier and heavier than traditional trays, which might be a consideration if you have limited space.

  7. Learning Curve: Some cats may take a while to get used to the new system and may be initially wary of it.

  8. Waste Disposal: Although they handle the bulk of the cleaning, you still need to dispose of the waste, which is often collected in a specialized container

In summary, self-cleaning litter trays offer a high level of convenience and hygiene, automating the waste removal process to save time and better control odors.

These features make them particularly appealing for busy pet owners or those with multiple cats. However, these benefits come at a cost, both in terms of initial purchase and potential ongoing maintenance.

The systems are also reliant on power sources and can be noisy, with complex mechanisms that could potentially malfunction.

Therefore, while self-cleaning litter trays present a convenient, time-saving option, they require a higher investment and ongoing care.


4. Self-Purifying Litter Trays:

Air purifying litter tray deodorizer
Self-purifying litter trays are an innovation in pet care, designed to maintain a cleaner and more sanitary environment for both cats and their owners.

They often use UV light or other forms of sterilization to kill bacteria and eliminate odors.

However, like all products, they have their pros and cons.

Pros:

    1. More cost effective than Self-Cleaning Trays: Self-purifying litter trays can be a more cost-effective compromise if you aren't quite ready to commit to a self-cleaning model.

    2. Auto-detection: Most models use an auto-detection feature that is triggered when your cat uses their tray, utilizing innovative technology, such as photocatalyst purifiers to sterilize and purify the surrounding air and helping to control urine and stool odour.
      This ensures a fresh-smelling environment for both the cat and the
      owner.

    3. Saves on litter: The deodorization process can significantly reduce the frequency of litter changes, saving time and money in the long run.

    4. Low Maintenance: While regular cleaning is still necessary, self-purifying capabilities can reduce the frequency with which you need to perform a thorough cleaning.

    5. Health Monitoring: Some advanced models may offer additional features like usage tracking, providing data that could be useful for monitoring your cat’s health.

    6. Attractiveness: Cats might find a cleaner, less odorous litter tray more inviting, encouraging consistent use.

    7. Safety: By killing harmful bacteria and parasites, self-purifying trays could potentially reduce the risk of disease transmission to humans and other pets.

 

Cons


  1. Cost: These trays are generally more expensive than traditional or even regular self-cleaning litter boxes, both in terms of initial purchase and possible ongoing costs for consumables like special litter or replacement parts.

  2. Power Requirements: Most self-purifying trays require an electrical source for the purifying function to work, limiting where they can be placed.

  3. Complexity: These trays may have more components that could break or malfunction, necessitating repairs or replacement.

  4. Noise: Depending on the technology used, some models could be noisy, potentially disturbing you or your cat.

  5. Limited Effectiveness: While purifying capabilities can reduce bacteria and odors, they are not a substitute for regular cleaning and maintenance.

  6. Safety Concerns: If improperly used or malfunctioning, the purifying elements (like UV light) could potentially pose a risk to pets or humans, though this is generally minimal if the product is well-designed and used correctly.

  7. Adaptation Period: Some cats may be wary of the new technology, requiring a period of adjustment.

  8. Waste Disposal: Despite the self-purifying feature, you'll still need to dispose of the waste manually unless the tray also includes self-cleaning functions.

In summary, similar to self-cleaning trays, self-purifying litter trays can be more expensive upfront compared to traditional trays.

The effectiveness of the odor control may also vary depending on the tray's design and the quality of the purifying system.

Nevertheless, for cat owners looking for a low-maintenance and odor-free litter box solution, self-purifying trays can be an excellent investment.


5. Litter Mats:


cat litter mat tray

Cats can mess the house if they are not taken care of.

Almost all cats like to cover their poops, and therefore you need to provide kitty litter mat.

After they are done with their business, their paws are usually messy and can easily litter the house.

So, they sometimes need a mat to clean their paws.

Pros

 

  1. Simple addition to your current setup: Litter mats, like the Floofi Litter Mat (Rectangle) - are not litter trays themselves, but they can be a practical and cost-effective addition to your existing setup. 

  2. Reduced Litter Tracking: Litter mats catch stray particles as your cat leaves the litter box, preventing litter from being tracked around the house.

  3. Easy Cleanup: Many litter mats are designed to be easy to clean. Some can be shaken out, vacuumed, or even rinsed off, making maintenance simple.

  4. Aesthetically Pleasing: Litter mats come in various colors, shapes, and sizes, allowing you to choose one that fits well with your home decor.

  5. Comfort for Pets: Some mats are made with soft materials that are gentle on your cat’s paws.

  6. Additional Hygiene: By capturing stray litter, the mat can also help to contain potential germs or parasites that might otherwise be tracked onto floors.

  7. Cost-Effective: Compared to other pet-care accessories like self-cleaning litter trays, litter mats are generally affordable.

Cons

1. Limited Effectiveness: While mats can reduce litter tracking, they can’t entirely eliminate it. Some stray litter is likely to escape, especially if your cat likes to dig or kick litter.

2. Regular Cleaning Required: Despite catching litter, the mats themselves need to be cleaned regularly to maintain their effectiveness and hygiene.

3. Occupies Space: Litter mats will take up extra floor space around the litter box, which might be a consideration in smaller living areas.

4. Chewing Hazard: Some cats might take an interest in chewing the mat, which could be harmful depending on the materials used.

5. Slipping: If not properly anchored, some litter mats may slip or slide around, especially on smooth flooring, which can be annoying or even hazardous. (All of KittyButtHut's litter mats comes with a grippy base to avoid this problem!)

6. Compatibility: Not all litter mats work well with all types of litter. For example, mats designed for larger particles might not be effective with finer litters. Paper or clay pellets work best with this sort of option.

    In summary, litter mats offer a convenient and cost-effective solution for reducing litter tracking and enhancing cleanliness around the litter box.

    They come in various styles to fit your decor and are generally easy to clean.

    However, they are not entirely foolproof, requiring regular maintenance, and may not be effective with all types of litter.

    They also take up additional space and could present issues like slipping or chewing hazards.

    6. Bonus: Decorative Litter Trays
    Cat litter tray cabinetCat flower pot litter tray

    Pros

    1. Aesthetic Appeal: These litter trays blend seamlessly into your home décor, effectively hiding the litter box from plain view.

    2. Privacy: The disguised structure can offer a greater sense of privacy for your cat, making them more comfortable.

    3. Reduced Odor and Mess: Being enclosed, these units can help contain odors and litter scatter to some extent.

    4. Multipurpose: Some designs offer additional utility, like shelving or storage space, alongside their function as a litter tray.

    5. Conversation Starter: The unique designs can act as conversation pieces when guests discover their dual functionality.

    6. Pet Harmony: In multi-pet homes, the disguise may deter dogs or other curious pets from investigating or tampering with the litter.

       

    Cons

    1.  Cost: Disguised litter trays are often more expensive than traditional options due to their dual functionality and design appeal.

       

    2.  Space Requirements: These units often require more floor space and may not fit conveniently in all living situations.

       

    3.  Cleaning Difficulty: The more intricate design could make cleaning and maintenance more cumbersome.

       

    4. Adaptation Time: Some cats may take a while to get used to the disguised format, particularly if they're used to open or straightforward enclosed trays.
    5. Visibility: Being disguised means you may not notice the need for cleaning as readily, which could impact hygiene.
    6. Ventilation: Some disguised models may have limited ventilation, which could concentrate odors inside the box.
    In summary, disguised litter trays offer an aesthetic and privacy-focused solution but come with trade-offs like higher cost, potentially more difficult cleaning, and space requirements. These trays are best suited for pet owners who prioritize home aesthetics and have the space and budget to accommodate them


    Conclusion:

    Cat stepping out of litter tray - shop premium cat supplies now

    When choosing a cat litter tray, it is essential to consider your cat's preferences, 

    In the quest for the perfect litter solution, cat owners have a plethora of options to consider, each with its own set of advantages and drawbacks.

    Open litter trays are affordable and easy to clean but offer little in the way of odor control or privacy.

    Enclosed litter trays enhance privacy and reduce odors, yet they can be harder to clean and may make some cats feel cramped.

    Self-cleaning litter trays offer the ultimate convenience by automating waste removal, but they come at a higher cost and still require some level of maintenance.

    Self-purifying trays bring in advanced technology to kill bacteria and manage odors, albeit at an even steeper price and with a need for an electrical source.

    Litter mats, while not a complete solution, serve as a cost-effective way to manage litter tracking, although they require regular cleaning.

    Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, lifestyle, and your cat’s preferences. By carefully weighing the pros and cons of each option, you can make an informed decision that benefits both you and your feline friend.
    Back to blog